Do you have a few presents under the tree already? They all look so appealing and good-intentioned, don’t they? Beneath the wrapping paper and bow, however, each gift has a different story to tell — about behavioral economics, gender dynamics, time management, and power dynamics. They also say a lot about you, the lucky recipient.
WePay makes it easy to collect money online, which means that we’ve seen a bunch of people collecting money for group gifts this holiday season. That got us thinking about the deeper truths behind all this holiday hoopla. The folks here at WePay sifted through a big pile of gift-giving research to find some surprising insights: What value do you think a recipient will place on the item you just bought and wrapped? What’s the value (and the fate) of the gift cards you’re sending to your siblings? Which do you value more: a gift from your parents or a gift from your significant other?
We dug through research from a variety of highly reputable sources – from chin-scratching academic papers out of Northwestern’s Kellogg School of Management to the latest surveys from Consumer Reports, retail trade groups, and even the good people behind National Regifting Day. The data is pretty compelling – and if you’re like me and haven’t even started your shopping – you may want to take a look at the graphic below before you head to the mall.
Let’s start with just basic gift valuation: That $50 sweater you got your house bro, or even your real bro? According to Wharton prof Joel Waldfogel, he’ll lowball its actual value as much as 18%. Because he doesn’t know the sweater market? Doesn’t like you? No – he’ll mentally mark it down simply because it’s a gift. If he were buying it himself, it’d be worth its price, or perhaps even more.
Then there’s the truly depressing economic circle of gift cards. Every year, millions of cards go unredeemed – this holiday season alone, gift givers will throw an estimated $2.5 billion down the toilet on gift-card recipients, who will either forget to use or simply never open them. So think about that the next time you’re in line at Safeway, staring at the gift card rack – with plastic offerings from Target and Apple to Gap and Nordstrom — believing how smart and efficient it would be to cross off five people on your list with the help of a single end-cap. Unused cards with billions of dollars of real economic value have become so rampant that companies like Cardpool are doing well helping people re-sell their unused cards at a discount.
This doesn’t mean you should follow in the footsteps of Ebenezer Scrooge, or rethink the holiday spirit in general. But at a time when many are still burdened by both the macro and micro effects of the economic downturn, it may be time to rethink what it really means to give a gift.
Embed the infographic above:


You should come out and say it: gift-giving kinda sucks.
Though I kind of weaseled on that conclusion as well when I wrote a similar blog post a year ago:
http://messymatters.com/scroogenomics
Thanks for the comment. Just read your post and thoroughly enjoyed it. Very good stuff.
If I get a $100 gift card, I’m likely to use $97 ($2.5 billion wasted out of $91 billion). And if I spend the $97 on a sweater, I would get something that I like/value/enjoy and one that would not sit unused.
Now, compare that to getting a $100 sweater – on average, the value I get from that sweater is likely to be less than if I had bought that sweater myself (say, if I had a gift card).
If that difference is more than 3%, then the gift card looks like a better deal. And, based on the gifts I’ve received in the past, the difference is more likely to be in the 50% range.
I’ll take a gift card over a sweater any day!
Leave it to an engineer to poke holes in my brilliant logic
I totally agree. I personally really enjoy getting gift cards, which is why I’m alway so surprised by the amount of gift-card breakage.
Pingback: The Economics of Holiday Gift Giving [INFOGRAPHIC]
Pingback: The Economics of Holiday Gift Giving [INFOGRAPHIC] | biz-top.com
Pingback: The Economics of Holiday Gift Giving [INFOGRAPHIC] | iuvo Shopper & Community Newspaper News
Loved this. And we’ve reproduced it on our blog too (using your specified embed code and a mention too)
Pingback: The Economics of Holiday Gift Giving [INFOGRAPHIC]
Pingback: TankedFISH » Blog Archive » Giftonomics
Pingback: Scroogenomics vs Ulterior Motives (and Other Justifications for Gift Giving) | Messy Matters
Pingback: Recipients Value Gifts Below Retail and Other Gift Stats (Infographic) | Real Estate Devlopment
[...] to those and several other questions pertaining to holiday gift-gifting.Among the more interesting findings:Nearly $1.3 billion will evaporate in unspent gift cards this year, simply because people [...]
Pingback: Giving Gifts, Just Plain Data Wrapped Nicely | How to Crush Without Being Crushed
Oh, heavens – have you hit a nerve! I just got my annual “re-gifted” box of stuff from an inlaw. She gets lots of useless things she doesn’t want, and sends it on to me for Christmas. Things like food mixes she can’t use because she’s always on a strict diet (I am too, unfortunately), Christmas themed kitchen items, sugar and creamer sets, etc. I’m in my 60′s and have no use for any of it – I just pass it on to Goodwill.
Overall, my advice is: don’t re-gift. If it’s useless to you, chances are it’ll be useless to whoever you re-gift it to. Plus, they’ll probably recognize it for what it is – something you didn’t want. Why not just agree with your friends and family to stop exchanging gifts?
Pingback: How Your Gifts Are Really Valued | Lifehacker Australia
Pingback: Infografía: La verdadera valoración de los regalos navideños | WebAyunate
Pingback: Blogbdon » How Much Santa is Really Spending on Yo Ass…
Pingback: Casalot
Pingback: All Toys for Tots – Christmas Morning | Happy Holiday
Pingback: The Economics of Holiday Gift Giving [INFOGRAPHIC] | World Latest News Title
Pingback: Koliko vrijede vaši pokloni? | Mihael Šanko
Pingback: Why The Gifts You Got Suck, But Don’t Suck | Weakonomi¢s
Pingback: Local acting group goes retro, spreads holiday cheer – Star Local … | Group Vacation Packages Are A Great Money Saver
Pingback: Holiday Misgivings: The Real Dynamics Behind Holiday Gifting | Cancel The News
Pingback: Christmas Misgivings :: Be the Change Book Club